Before you hire an AI SEO agency, ask it to show you the work. A screenshot of your name in an AI answer is a useful observation. It is not a strategy.
A credible AI SEO engagement should make your site accessible, improve the pages buyers use to decide, strengthen accurate evidence about the business and measure visibility alongside qualified enquiries. Ask what will be delivered, what is uncertain and how you can check progress yourself.
The useful bits, at a glance
- Look for work on access, useful content, credible evidence and measurement.
- Ask agencies to explain the delivery scope and the limits of their claims.
- A pilot can establish a baseline and deliver work; it cannot guarantee rankings.
In this guide
- What does "AI SEO" actually mean?
- What should an AI SEO agency do?
- What should an AI SEO agency not sell you?
- How should results be reported?
- What questions should you ask before hiring one?
- What a realistic first month can deliver
- A pilot brief that protects both sides
- Frequently asked questions
- Start with a check
What does "AI SEO" actually mean?
The phrase gets used for two very different things.
- SEO for AI search. Getting your firm named in AI-generated answers. This is also called generative engine optimisation (GEO), answer engine optimisation (AEO) or LLM SEO.
- SEO done with AI tools. An agency using software to produce content or audits faster.
The first is a service you might want. The second is an internal method, and it tells you nothing about results. When you talk to an agency, ask which one they mean. Our view is set out on our AI search page.
What should an AI SEO agency do?
Assess the work against clear delivery criteria for each part.
| Area | What good looks like | What to be wary of |
|---|---|---|
| Access | Checks robots.txt for Googlebot, Bingbot and OAI-SearchBot; confirms text is in the HTML; verifies Bing Webmaster Tools | Skipping this because "the site is fine" |
| Research | A fixed list of real buyer questions, tested across several AI tools, several times each | One screenshot of one ChatGPT answer |
| Pages | Answer-first rewrites of your highest-value service pages, with sources, numbers and named authors | Dozens of generic blog posts produced at volume |
| Mentions | Aligning how directories, professional bodies, review sites and press describe you | Buying links or mass-posting on forums |
| Classic SEO | Technical fixes, local search, links and rankings, because AI answers draw on search results | Treating GEO as a replacement for SEO |
| Reporting | Enquiries and won clients first, visibility second | Traffic charts and "impressions" as the headline |
The original GEO research found that changes such as adding relevant evidence affected visibility in its experimental systems. That is useful research, not a reliable uplift forecast for a commercial website. Test improvements against your own buyer questions and observed outcomes.

What should an AI SEO agency not sell you?
A few things come up often enough to name.
Do not treat llms.txt as a visibility guarantee. Google does not require a special AI file for its search features. Prioritise accessible pages, accurate business information and useful content; ask any supplier to show evidence for additional work.
Content volume for its own sake. Fifty thin articles written quickly will not get you cited. One excellent page on a question your buyers ask might.
Traffic as the only proof. Visits help diagnose acquisition, but they do not establish the value of an enquiry or customer. Ask for separate reporting on search performance, observed AI citations and commercial outcomes. Falling traffic is not evidence that AI visibility is improving.
How should results be reported?
This is our position, and it is why we exist: most agencies report traffic, we report customers.
A useful monthly report from an AI SEO agency should answer, in this order:
- How many enquiries came in, and how many were qualified?
- How many became clients, and what are they worth (counted by your finance team, not the agency)?
- Where did they say they found you?
- How often are you named across the fixed question list, by tool?
- What changed on the site and off it, and what is next?
Judge the work using evidence the business can check: qualified enquiries, customer records and invoiced revenue. Keep changes in rankings or clicks separate from those commercial outcomes. Our results page explains the evidence behind published Pieo engagements.
What questions should you ask before hiring one?
- Which crawlers do you check, and what do you do if our site blocks one?
- Show me how you test whether we appear in AI answers. How many questions, how many runs?
- Which of our pages would you change first, and why those?
- How do you build third-party mentions without buying links or spamming forums?
- What does your monthly report lead with?
- Who counts a won client: you or us?
- Is there any tactic you would refuse to use?
Compare those answers with the evidence behind the agency’s case studies.
What a realistic first month can deliver
A first month can establish the baseline, agree the priority pages and scope, implement approved changes, and review what has been delivered. The next 90-day plan should reflect the evidence. Rankings, AI citations and leads cannot be promised on a 30-day deadline. See how the Pieo pilot works.
A pilot brief that protects both sides
A pilot is useful when it reduces uncertainty. It becomes dangerous when the sales pitch turns a delivery deadline into a ranking deadline.
Agree a narrow commercial focus before work begins: one priority service, one market and a defined set of buyer questions. Then write down the baseline, access requirements, page changes, responsibilities and day-30 handover. Specify the number and type of pages after reviewing the work involved, rather than selling an arbitrary publishing quota.
| Ask for | Evidence you can inspect | What it does not promise |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline | Saved queries, answers, sources and dates | A complete census of all AI users |
| Technical checks | Identified issues and verified fixes | Guaranteed crawling or indexing |
| Content improvements | Approved pages, sources and internal links | A fixed AI ranking |
| Measurement | Working enquiry tracking and a review plan | A set number of leads in 30 days |
Ask who supplies subject expertise, who approves claims and who publishes. If your team has to write every page and chase every implementation, the headline fee does not describe the real cost of the engagement.
At the review, separate completed work from early signals. A repaired indexing problem is a completed task. A first citation is an early signal. An attributable customer is a commercial outcome. Reporting them as different things makes it easier to decide whether to continue.
Pieo’s 30-day pilot is framed around a baseline, agreed improvements and the next 90-day plan. The purpose is to give both teams evidence and a practical working relationship before committing to a longer programme.
- Baseline
Know the starting point
- Agreed work
Fix, improve and verify
- Review
Decide the next 90 days
A practical framework from Pieo
Frequently asked questions
Is an AI SEO agency different from a normal SEO agency?
It should do everything a good SEO agency does, plus the work specific to AI answers: quotable pages, third-party consistency and AI visibility tracking. If it drops classic SEO, it is missing the base AI answers are built on.
How long before we see results?
Crawler and page fixes can show in weeks because AI tools search the live web. Mentions and reputation take months. Revenue follows enquiries, which depends on your sales cycle.
Should we hire a specialist in our sector?
It helps. Law and accountancy have regulatory rules and buyer questions that a generalist will take time to learn. Ask any agency to show you the buyer questions they would test for your firm.
What if our own site gets little search traffic today?
That is common, and it is not a reason to wait. For what it is worth, Pieo's own site gets very little search traffic today, and we are working on that like anyone else. Judge any agency on the results it can show from its clients' own numbers.
Start with a check
Want more revenue from Google and ChatGPT? Enter your website at our free Search Check. Our team reviews every site and you hear back within one working day.


.jpeg)
%2520(1).jpeg)
